Wikipedia:WikiProject Comics/Notice board

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

size Comics Portal
WikiProject Comics talk
⇒ Get Involved talk
⇒ Notice Board talk
⇒ Peer Review talk
⇒ Request Cleanup talk
⇒ Tasks to be Completed talk
Category:WikiProject Comics
 v • d • e 
Shortcuts:
WP:CMC/NB
WP:CMC/BOARD

Welcome to WikiProject Comics (WP:CMC), a project formed by Wikipedians to increase, expand, improve, and better organize articles related to comics in Wikipedia, the largest encyclopaedia in the world! We rely on comics enthusiasts worldwide to make this the best comics encyclopaedia on the web. If you are interested in participating, why not see how you can get involved?

Contents

Action items

Deletion discussions

To edit these sections, see this page

Articles

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion
See also: Wikipedia:WikiProject Deletion sorting/Comics and animation


Categories

Wikipedia:Categories for discussion

Images and media

Wikipedia:Images and media for deletion


Redirects

Wikipedia:Redirects for discussion


Templates

Wikipedia:Templates for deletion


PROD

Wikipedia:Proposed deletion

Deletion review

Wikipedia:Deletion review


Requested moves, merges, and splits

To edit these sections, see moves, merges, and splits

Requested moves



Proposed merges

Proposed splits

Proposed merges (2007)


Proposed splits (2007)


Requests for comment

To edit these sections, see articles, user conduct, or misc.

Articles

This section is specifically for requests for comments notices, not cleanup requests, or peer review.
  • User:Ntnon/Kirby: The (bizarrely) excised section from Jack Kirby detailling his legal and moral battles with Marvel over the return of his artwork, was apparently removed for being "opinion" and partisan and all the rest of it. Probably because it's difficult to write completely objectively about this when almost all comment and coverage has (probably rightly) condemned Marvel utterly for their behaviour towards Kirby. In any case, all comments and advice welcome - I wondered whether there were worries raised about neutrality because of the potential DC vs. Marvel angle of parts chronicling the facts about DC returning artwork before Marvel; writing letters in support of Kirby, etc. so I tried to tone those parts down somewhat.
Help welcome. :o) ntnon (talk) 03:00, 17 May 2008 (UTC)
  • Pat Lee: User:Hyrocomics keeps on adding/rewriting the article Pat Lee, disregarding the cited controversies this artist have. The user basically leans on the side of article's subject. †Bloodpack† 13:57, 26 March 2008 (UTC)
  • Gotham City Police Department: The article says in the section 'Current status of GCPD' that "Maggie Sawyer [...] has ended her relationship with former lover Toby Raines". However, none of the main DC publications seems to indicate that this is true. The last time the relationship came up was in 52 (comic book), where it's said that Toby's move to Gotham will be delayed. Where was it stated that they broke up? Was it stated at all? -- Anval (talk) 09:20, 01 February 2008 (UTC)
  • The Program (disambiguation): A user has blocked three different users' attempts to add a redlink pointing to The Programme (comics), arguing that "it isn't notable". I couldn't find anything to help in WP:MOSDAB#Red links (which only talks about what red links shouldn't be included) or WP:NB ("this guideline does not presently provide notability criteria for the following types of publications: comic books"; not that notability guidelines apply to redlinks anyway). I cited WP:RED's "In general, red links should not be removed if they link to something that could plausibly sustain an article." and he's still standing his ground, so we're at somewhat of an impasse. (Apologies for earlier uncivil wording of this post.) --DocumentN (talk) 18:17, 28 January 2008 (UTC)


Users


Miscellaneous


Articles (2007)

  • Comic Guaranty LLC (a.k.a. CGC) - In my opinion, the article is very slanted against the company. However, another editor feels otherwise. It's been a protracted dispute as opposed to a brightly burning edit war. --GentlemanGhost 01:27, 10 June 2007 (UTC)
    • Update: In my absense, there has been increased edit warring on this article between two anonymous users. At a glance, it doesn't look like anyone has violated 3RR, but it's a useless edit war nonetheless. --GentlemanGhost 11:35, 4 November 2007 (UTC)


Arbitration

Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration

Open cases

To edit this section, see this page

Enforcement requested

For User:Asgardian violation of an Arbitration ruling against him. He has been notified on his talk page. Request posted here. --Tenebrae (talk) 19:58, 17 April 2008 (UTC)


Recent creations

To edit this section, see this page

June 2008

May 2008

April 2008