Wikipedia:Release Version Nominations/Set Nominations/Woodworking

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Contents

[edit] List of articles related to Woodworking tools

[edit] Top

  1. Woodworking Poor B
  2. Hand saw Start
  3. Sandpaper B
  4. Plane (tool) Decent B
  5. Saw B
  6. Carpenter Short B
  7. Chisel Short B
  8. Clamp (tool) Start, mainly a list
  9. Wood as a medium B

[edit] High

  1. Circular saw Usable Start
  2. Timber Weak B
  3. Wood carving Short B
  4. Wood GA
  5. Woodworking joints Usable Start
  6. Cabinet making Short B, weak on refs but usable
  7. Block plane Stub/start
  8. Belt sander Start
  9. Wood grain Stub with pix
  10. Table saw B, but lacks pix
  11. Butt joint Nice B
  12. Rasp Stub/start
  13. Framing hammer Stub/start
  14. Japanese carpentry Weak start
  15. Mallet Start
  16. Gouge Stub/start
  17. Hatchet Stub
  18. Dowel Stub
  19. Wood router B

[edit] B

  1. Wood as a medium Usable B, though it lacks refs
  2. History of wood carving Long B, lacks refs except 1911B, cleanup tag, usable
  3. Biscuit joiner Weak B, low importance

[edit] Discussion

Many of these articles are little more than stubs, and most lack references. However, there is some good content in here, and many nice diagrams and pictures. I would suggest limiting the selection to the following:

  1. Woodworking Poor B
  2. Sandpaper B
  3. Plane (tool) Decent B
  4. Saw B
  5. Carpenter Short B
  6. Chisel Short B
  7. Circular saw Usable Start
  8. Timber Weak B
  9. Wood carving Short B
  10. Wood GA
  11. Woodworking joints Usable Start
  12. Cabinet making Short B, weak on refs but usable
  13. Table saw B, but lacks pix
  14. Butt joint Nice B
  15. Wood router B
  16. Wood as a medium Usable B, though it lacks refs
  17. History of wood carving Long B, lacks refs except 1911B, cleanup tag, usable

I think the others need to be stronger before we include any of them. Walkerma 01:52, 8 May 2007 (UTC)

I've added most (14) of these, but omitted three on further examination. I think the Start-Class ones I mentioned are just too weak to include, and the History of wood carving article does need a rewrite. Walkerma 03:22, 18 June 2007 (UTC)