Talk:MTV Europe Music Awards

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Too american?

Let me explain why I got rid of the following passage (at first I added the "citation needed" tag but my explanation will explain why I changed my mind about that as well):

MTV Europe Music Awards is often criticized as being too American and out of touch with music that is popular in continental Europe. Organizers of the 12th MTV Europe Music Awards 2005, November 3rd in Lisbon, Portugal hoped to change that and give back the European touch to the show.

That's the definition of weasel words. First of all, "often" doesn't mean anything, and even if it was a specific term, "often" wouldn't be the right one because (and I realize i'm nitpicking and exaggerating) that could mean one person says it every day which is far from the implied meaning. The second issue is that there's no standard definition of "too American" and again, it doesn't say who's saying that. So even if it were possible to prove that a significant number of people considered it "too American", the article would still have to specify who those people are, and there would be no guarantee they all meant the same thing by "too American". Furthermore, while I can't imagine anyone taking it personally, that's somewhat offensive to the American population because it presents being American as a bad thing. Again, I doubt anyone would take it personally, but it still not really right. The final issue with this section is the assertion about the organizers in Portugal. First, obviously, there needs to be a source. Second, it has to specify which specific people felt that way and address why that goal is important. Finally, what exactly is "the European touch to the show"?

Now, don't think I go around explaining all my edits with long things like this, but because this has been on the page so long I figured it's more likely someone will come along who will disagree with me. -Unknownwarrior33 00:04, 7 August 2006 (UTC)

I think the point is that its a European Awards show, not an American show, yet most of the nominees are American artists even though there is a massive European music scene and you are being far to sensitive to see it as being offensive.

[edit] The biggest?

At the EMAs I was told it being the largest music awards show in the world, even surpassing the size of the VMAs and the Grand Prix de l'Eurovision. Can anyone fact this out? --lynX

VMA's - no way, it is worldwide; Eurovision Song contest - Different category, not comparable. --T2t2 19:28, 3 September 2007 (UTC)

LINKIN PARK'S AWARD STATUS

linkin park won an award for Band of 2007 today (November 1st) so they now have 5 awards putting them in second place behind eminem (just thought i should mention it) —Preceding unsigned comment added by 81.233.2.176 (talk) 22:24, 1 November 2007 (UTC)

but as far as i can see Linkin Park has only won 4 awards, not 5 --Felizdenovo 22:39, 1 November 2007 (UTC)

[edit] EMA 2007

Best Russian Act will be announced only tomorrow (November 2). So it's a good idea to keep the Current Template there --Felizdenovo 22:32, 1 November 2007 (UTC)