User talk:Frikazoyd

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Zombie Panic!

Hi Frikazoyd, I've had a look at the references you added. What we are looking for is reliable, non-trivial, independent coverage. (By reliable, we mean somewhere with editorial oversight and a reputation for reliability.)

• The digg.com page is entirely generated by its users (in this case both the submission and the comments) so we can't allow that as a reliable source.
• I'm not familiar with Kotaku, but it looks acceptable. However, the coverage looks like a press release, which we would classify as "trivial". Okay for verifiability, but not for notability.
• The bluenews.com is, again, a very short press release with lots of user comments, so no good for notability.

In conclusion, I think some alternative references should be found (I will look for some myself at some point) but we must remain open to the possibility that this mod doesn't meet the notability threshold. Marasmusine (talk) 20:47, 3 January 2008 (UTC)