User talk:Ujmi
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
[edit] Ali Sina
Nothing happened to Ali Sina's page, what are you talking about? You may delete this message after you see it. Which sections were lost? I reorganized that page, nothing else. Check it carefully. --Matt57 10:59, 31 October 2006 (UTC)
- If there are any facts deleted from Ali's page, you should put them in there. Nowadays I'm monitoring this page so I'll make sure no one deletes it. Before you think the page is there to advertise Ali Sina, remember that this page IS about Ali Sina so you'll find lots of 'advertisement' in that page about him. This is true for any biography. I look forward to your contributions there. There is almost no content in the criticism section. I think the problem is difficulty in finding notable people who have criticized Ali Sina. --Matt57 23:17, 20 November 2006 (UTC)
- He doesnt come out in open debate because of the fear of assasination (e.g Van Goh). I saw the criticism section with many points which were there long time ago but deleted. But the thing is this and they were rightly deleted: You cant link to his debates and say "he says stuff out of context". If you want to say he's out of context, you have to quote a known notable person who says that. It cant be your own judgement. Whatever changes you want to do, they must have good references and they must not be your own deductions. This is why its an encyclopedia, its not a collection of personal opinions, but rather facts. If you think e.g. the presentation was removed, you have to give proof for it etc. Basically its simple: You can put anything in there about Ali Sina, as long as its referenced and someone notable has said that.--Matt57 22:58, 21 November 2006 (UTC)
Whose e-mails has Ali Sina distorted on his webpage? You have to admit that Zakir Naik insists upon the presence of 10,000 people because he knows that Ali Sina would be a fool to consent to such a thing. Arrow740 08:38, 22 November 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Welcome in wikipedia
Welcome to wikipedia. Please join Wikipedia:WikiProject Islam and help us in improving Islam related articles. You can post message on its talk page and hopfully someone will reply. Please be active and work together. --- ALM 09:31, 14 December 2006 (UTC)
