Talk:The Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] French title

Did the French title contain the comma in it? It seems quite unusual to me; I found it in several sources via Google, but I also found some sources without the comma (and even few sources saying that it was Memoires De La Vie Privee de Benjamin Franklin). -- Sandius 12:18, 18 August 2005 (UTC)

Hi, Sandius. I'm not sure what that comma is supposed to signify. When I made changes to this article, I conformed (and expanded) the title based on the way it's listed on p. 361 of the "Norton Critical Edition" listed under the "Sources" section. That gives a section of "Key Editions of Franklin's Autobiography" that lists and explains the various early publications in French and English. I went by the title I found there. -MollyTheCat 11:29, 23 August 2005 (UTC)

[edit] Unknown reason for edit

My sentence "He had intended this as a basis for a projected sect but, Franklin says, did not pursue the project" had someone insert a question mark in parentheses near the words "projected sect." I am not sure why this addition was made unless it was vandalism, but I have reverted to the previous form. Perhaps the person who added this question mark, if he/she had a reason for doing so, can explain here the concern he/she was trying to express? I think the statement I wrote was factually accurate with reference to Franklin's book unless I've misunderstood what he said. Thanks. -MollyTheCat 01:53, 8 November 2005 (UTC)

[edit] Another edit re-edited

Someone has added the following sentence at the beginning of the "Publication history" section:

"The Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin is on the hundred most banned books list published by the American Library Association for 'social reasons'...."

I don't know the source for this claim, but have no reason to doubt it. However, this is not the most appropriate place for the comment, and I am therefore moving it to put it in the final section under reactions to the book, which seems a more logical position. -MollyTheCat 04:59, 23 December 2005 (UTC)

francis moloan is a famous artist what about ben frank