Talk:The 50 Greatest Cartoons
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Contents |
[edit] Copyvio
I am removing the list itself as well as the link to the list. This is obviously copyvio as this is a published copyrighted book from 1994. Moonside 02:34, 28 June 2007 (UTC)
- Actually, a list of titles of cartoons is not copyvio. If any of the actual content from the book was reproduced here, then yes that would be a violation, but merely relaying the list itself is not.
plattopustalk 05:59, 6 July 2007 (UTC)
- This article was previously deleted as a copyright violation and then undeleted at DRV on the condition that the list was excluded. Many people believe these types of lists are copyright violation, but the important point is that it was decided by consensus to exculde the list, so anyone re-adding it is going against the consensus decision. Masaruemoto 02:31, 25 July 2007 (UTC)
- Can you provide a link? That completely goes against logic. A list of cartoon titles can not be copyrighted. There are already MANY articles on Wikipedia that reproduce certain lists (for example, Top 100 film lists, etc) which are not even considered for copyvio. plattopustalk 23:36, 28 August 2007 (UTC)
- Can you provide a link? That completely goes against logic. A list of cartoon titles can not be copyrighted. There are already MANY articles on Wikipedia that reproduce certain lists (for example, Top 100 film lists, etc) which are not even considered for copyvio.
- This article was previously deleted as a copyright violation and then undeleted at DRV on the condition that the list was excluded. Many people believe these types of lists are copyright violation, but the important point is that it was decided by consensus to exculde the list, so anyone re-adding it is going against the consensus decision. Masaruemoto 02:31, 25 July 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Removing "trailers" unrelated to book
There may be a lot of great cartoons out there, but this isn't the place to link to them or their trailers, unless they're discussed in this specific book. :) Moonriddengirl 17:29, 3 July 2007 (UTC)
[edit] 1994 or 2007 and Saved By the Bell or What's Opera Doc?
Why Does the list have (2007) next to it even if the book was written in 1994. Also why is Saved By the Bell number one instead of What's Opera Duck? Which is known to be number one.
- Someone seems to be playing games, given that Saved by the Bell isn't even a cartoon. It is most peculiar. Moonriddengirl 01:37, 12 July 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Which animation industry?
"The list itself aimed to be authoritative by taking votes from 1000 people working in the animation industry."
Which animation industry? Judging by the selections, I think that they likely didn't ask an international sample of people but only from North America (or only from the US). If true, this should be mentioned in the article. Esn (talk) 05:49, 29 May 2008 (UTC)
