User talk:SurfsUp

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Re: Harbour Island

Hi SurfsUp. Thanks for your message. It's good to get feedback even if not necessarily in agreement. My disambiguating Harbour/Harbor Island/Islets was not so much because I saw it as necessary (you are quite right - not strictly necessary, at least not at present) but more as being useful. The three pages disambiguated had very similar, though not identical, names and, my own experience tells me, could have led to confusion, especially since the Bahamas island is sometimes spelt 'Harbor' on US websites. Moreover, some googling found a few more places with the same or very similar name that could appear on Wikipedia in future. So I felt that, increasingly, the disambig was moving towards 'necessary'. However, if you wish to switch the Bahamas island back, please feel free to do so. Cheers.Maias (talk) 23:49, 17 February 2008 (UTC)