User talk:Stilllettto500

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Judd Winick

You stated in your Edit Summary when you deleted a criticism of Winick's work that "Someone griping on a blog doesn't merit inclusion." First of all, whether you consider a given critique to be "griping" does not mean that it does not merit inclusion, since your personal point of view is not a viable critieria for judging this, given WP's NPOV policy. Second, the Comics Journal isn't a blog. It's a major publication of the comic book industry published by Fantagraphics Books, which is clearly indicated on that page that's linked to. Nothing on it indicates that it's a blog. Nightscream 06:40, 6 October 2006 (UTC)