Wikipedia talk:Requests for adminship/Luckyluke (2nd nomination)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

      Go back to see caveats or to check another user.

User:Luckyluke

      run at Tue Feb 27 21:54:25 2007 GMT

Category talk:  4
Category:       3
Image:  116
Mainspace       2035
Portal talk:    1
Portal: 3
Talk:   711
Template talk:  2
Template:       29
User talk:      64
User:   42
Wikipedia talk: 25
Wikipedia:      233
avg edits per article   2.18
earliest        20:40, 5 October 2004
number of unique articles       1500
total   3268
2004/10         8       
2004/11         0       
2004/12         0       
2005/1  53      
2005/2  0       
2005/3  0       
2005/4  18      
2005/5  25      
2005/6  40      
2005/7  20      
2005/8  47      
2005/9  19      
2005/10         6       
2005/11         3       
2005/12         0       
2006/1  226     
2006/2  32      
2006/3  46      
2006/4  122     
2006/5  93      
2006/6  27      
2006/7  35      
2006/8  230     
2006/9  262     
2006/10         435     
2006/11         433     
2006/12         66      
2007/1  463     
2007/2  559     


Mainspace
81      Twins (band)
56      Gillian Chung
55      Collingwood School
55      West Vancouver, British Columbia
46      Charlene Choi
41      Vancouver
34      Marriott International
31      Hong Kong
28      Donald Trump
26      Jessica Alba
26      Storyeum
24      Ella Koon
22      Jackie Chan
22      Shangri-La Hotels and Resorts
21      Royal Canadian Air Cadets
Talk:
13      Gillian Chung
9       Twins (band)
9       Charlene Choi
8       Vancouver
7       Edison Chen
7       Hong Kong
6       Blair Wilson
6       Collingwood School
5       Vancouver (disambiguation)
5       Gigi Leung
5       Isabella Leong
5       List of shopping malls in Canada
5       West Vancouver, British Columbia
4       Rob-B-Hood
4       Albert Yeung
Category talk:
2       Banks of Hong Kong
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
Category:
2       Virtual Communities in Hong Kong
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
Image:
4       GillianHead.png
3       Richmondnightmarket.jpg
3       TwinsNewDrinkCommercial.png
3       CharleneHead.png
3       CharleneDrinkAd.png
3       Jwmarriottjr.jpg
2       Twins-avep.jpg
2       Round square.gif
2       CIMG1065.JPG
2       Gw-73.jpg
2       Issy 4seasons.jpg
2       Capcollege.jpg
2       Twinsincomparableconcert.jpg
2       Bctli.jpg
         
Portal:
2       Vancouver/Showcase Picture/Candidates
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
Template:
6       WikiProject Hong Kong/to do
5       WikiProject Hong Kong
3       Vancouver landmarks
3       HKCOTM
3       Concerts
2       HKCOTMN
2       WikiProject WikiProject Hong Kong/to do
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
Template talk:
2       Concerts
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
User:
34      Luckyluke
2       Okradee
2       Luckyluke/WikiProject Hotels
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
User talk:
15      Luckyluke
4       Pinkululu
3       Buchanan-Hermit
2       Deadkid dk
2       Kittybrewster
2       BorgHunter
2       Sir Studieselot
2       NawlinWiki/Archive 4
2       HongQiGong
2       Theorb
2       Cheung1303
2       Celtic0106
2       Okradee
2       Eliminatex
2       131.246.120.30
Wikipedia:
43      WikiProject Hong Kong
10      Canadian Wikipedians' notice board
9       WikiProject Vancouver
8       Arbitration Committee Elections January 2006/Candidate statements/Luckyluke
8       WikiProject Hong Kong/COTM
6       Articles for deletion/List of Marriott hotels
6       Articles for deletion/Real Social Dynamics
5       Requests for adminship/Luckyluke (2nd nomination)
5       WikiProject Hong Kong/Assessment
4       HK wikipedians' notice board
4       Requests for expansion
3       WikiProject Vancouver/COTM
3       Editor review/Luckyluke
3       Articles for deletion/Northholm Grammar School
3       Requests for adminship/Luckyluke
Wikipedia talk:
23      WikiProject Hong Kong
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         



If there were any problems, please email Interiot or post at User talk:Interiot.
Based directly on these URLs: [1]

[edit] ais523's research into Luckyluke's contribution history

First, the automated edit-summary sorting (using [[User:ais523/editcount|ais523's edit counter). Luckyluke used to not use edit summaries (although they have got better in this regard), so this is only really useful for recent edits. Article namespace: 2054

Manual vandalism reverts: 239
Automatic (rollback/script/tool) reverts: 1
Manual reverts not marked as vandalism reverts: 127
Removals: 13
XfD deletion-related tagging: 4
Speedy deletion-related tagging: 2
Deletion-related edit summaries: 55
Addition-related edit summaries: 134
Unknown abbreviation (≤4 characters): 17
Unrecognised edit summary: 474
Edits to sections, with no further summary: 222
No edit summary: 766
Talk namespace: 716
Manual vandalism reverts: 2
Deletion-related edit summaries: 15
Addition-related edit summaries: 247
Unrecognised tag ({{ in summary): 60
Unknown abbreviation (≤4 characters): 4
Unrecognised edit summary: 64
Edits to sections, with no further summary: 30
No edit summary: 294
User namespace: 42
XfD deletion-related tagging: 1
Addition-related edit summaries: 3
Unknown abbreviation (≤4 characters): 1
Unrecognised edit summary: 6
No edit summary: 31
User talk namespace: 69
Manual vandalism reverts: 1
XfD deletion-related tagging: 1
Deletion-related edit summaries: 14
Unrecognised edit summary: 25
Edits to sections, with no further summary: 7
No edit summary: 21
Wikipedia namespace: 237
Manual vandalism reverts: 1
Manual reverts not marked as vandalism reverts: 1
XfD deletion-related tagging: 5
Speedy deletion-related tagging: 7
Deletion-related edit summaries: 50
Addition-related edit summaries: 37
Non-deletion voting-related edit summaries: keep: 3, oppose: 1, support: 1
Unrecognised tag ({{ in summary): 1
Unknown abbreviation (≤4 characters): 1
Unrecognised edit summary: 69
Edits to sections, with no further summary: 28
No edit summary: 32
Wikipedia talk namespace: 27
Deletion-related edit summaries: 9
Addition-related edit summaries: 2
Unrecognised edit summary: 8
Edits to sections, with no further summary: 5
No edit summary: 3
Image namespace: 118
Deletion-related edit summaries: 1
Unrecognised tag ({{ in summary): 10
Unrecognised edit summary: 41
Edits to sections, with no further summary: 2
No edit summary: 64
Template namespace: 30
Addition-related edit summaries: 4
Unknown abbreviation (≤4 characters): 1
Unrecognised edit summary: 11
No edit summary: 14
Template talk namespace: 2
Addition-related edit summaries: 1
No edit summary: 1
Category namespace: 3
No edit summary: 3
Category talk namespace: 4
Addition-related edit summaries: 2
Unrecognised tag ({{ in summary): 2
Portal namespace: 3
Unrecognised edit summary: 2
Edits to sections, with no further summary: 1
Portal talk namespace: 1
Unrecognised edit summary: 1
Total: 3306

One interesting statistic here is the total 367 reverts in article-space (out of the 1066 edits with edit summaries), compared to the 69 edits in the User talk namespace, which would imply that the candidate tends not to warn vandals. Checking manually through all Luckyluke's User talk contributions reveals only two vandalism warnings; neither was substed, and one was subsequently removed (by Luckyluke).

Here's the output of the diff-generator (using the same edit counter and considering the most recent 2000 edits):

Luckyluke's AfD contributions here look more or less fine; the 419eater.com nomination was maybe unfortunate (Luckyluke seems a bit too fast to declare non-notability; this is the revision he put up for AfD), but it looks like a simple mistake rather than a misunderstanding of policy (the article wasn't sourced ridiculously well and many deletable articles have looked superficially similar). However, there are pretty much no other processes in which Luckyluke has participated regularly recently (the five RfA subpage edits are all to this RfA), and no process or policy discussion ('others in Wikipedia talk' doesn't appear in the list above because there were less than 5, and neither of them were policy-related). So in other words:

  • The candidate would make a good AfD closer, but has little to no other experience in process.
  • The candidate has moderate experience with images, but not enough recent IfDs to make it into the chart above (there is one IfD in the random selection at 'others in Wikipedia space' in the diffs).
  • The candidate spends a moderate proportion of their time vandalfighting (although not as much as many vandalfighting users) but doesn't warn people after reverts and doesn't understand about user warning templates.
  • The candidate has no or little experience in policy discussion.
  • The candidate has no or little experience in page protection or blocking (two things mentioned in the Q1 answer)

So I'm opposing weakly; although the candidate would benefit Wikipedia with helping to reduce AfD backlogs when they develop and speeding that up, some of that can already be done as a non-admin, and the participation in other areas in which the candidate wants to work is either nonexistent or hasn't been done with the knowledge of the process that I would expect an admin to have. --ais523 15:36, 2 March 2007 (UTC)