Talk:Pál Prónay

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] NPOV questions?

OK, Shlimozzle here. I started the Pal Pronay page; and I know I don't own it; it belongs to Wikipedia and the world. But with that said, I'm afraid that putting an NPOV banner with no rationale, and doing it anonymously (as an editor recently did), is not (in my extremely modest opinion) an acceptable way to raise objections or contribute to the conversation. Is this page really non-NPOV? I certainly worked very hard to avoid being biased in either direction, to cite sources (and more than just the primary source, Mr. Bobo). I might have done an inadequate job; but unless the editor who makes an objection is willing to provide a justification for it, I think the NPOV warning banner amounts to an unfair critique, and is unjustified. So after loading this posting, I'll be removing the banner. I don't consider this question to be resolved - any objections should and can be raised, and I welcome them. Shlimozzle (talk) 12:39, 5 June 2008 (UTC)