Talk:National Health Federation

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Links

If you enclose the title of a page between two square brackets it becomes a link to that page. For example enzyme links to the enzyme article. Putting more letters before or after the link means they are merged into the link eg enzymes. If you want to link to one page with a different wording, put a vertical bar between the page title and the link text eg link text. TimVickers 02:39, 16 April 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Secondary sources and neutrality

This article needs reliable secondary sources describing the NHF, rather than solely rehashing what's on its website. The reason for this is that the NHF is a lobbying organization with a clear agenda. Many of its positions are described here in the most favorable of terms, when in fact they are quite controversial. For example, "educating the public about the dangers of vaccination" could be re-parsed as "playing up scientifically unfounded fears and misleading people into avoiding a proven health intervention." There are multiple other examples in the article as written - it's as if the Operation Rescue page was sourced entirely to their website and said, "OR was founded to prevent the ongoing murder of innocent fetuses." The solution is to provide some reliable secondary sources, or at least balance it with perhaps equally partisan sources from another viewpoint. For example, Quackwatch's page on the NHF claims that the organization promotes a number of unproven therapies in which its members sometimes have a financial interest, and that over 20 of its board members have been in legal trouble for such issues. Again, Quackwatch has its own agenda, but the solution is to find some reliable secondary sources. MastCell ^Talk 21:58, 18 April 2007 (UTC)

There is no question that this article is all fluff and no substance. Looks like I'll have to pull myself away from doing research on the current Trudeau v CPB (ongoing) lawsuit to cleanup this article up. TheDevilYouKnow 18:53, 2 June 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Update June 16, 2007

OK I've added a Further Reading section with some links to books and papers regarding the NHF and more. There was one more that I was considering whether or not I wanted to add. Fads & Fallacies In the Name of Science by Martin Gardner. The cover tells you exactly what it's all about. The curious theories of modern pseudoscientists and the strange, amusing and alarming cults that surround them. A study in human gullibility. However, I really think this one would fit much better over at either the Kevin Trudeau or Natural Cures article. If anyone believes it should be included I will post it a link to the preview (google). TheDevilYouKnow 01:11, 17 June 2007 (UTC)