| Best Feature: |
Mud Season Director: Anthony Hall |
| John Garfield Award for Best Actor: (tie) |
Noble Willingham and The Corndog Man in Russ DeWees and Mud Season |
| Geraldine Page Award for Best Actress: |
Linda Shing, in Mud Season |
| Best Director of a Feature Film: |
Richard Schenkman, Went to Coney Island on a Mission from God, Be Back By Five |
| Best Screenplay in a Feature: |
Richard Schenkman, Went to Coney Island on a Mission from God, Be Back By Five |
| Maverick Award for Quality in a Low-budget film: |
My Brother Jack Director: Anthony Caldarella |
| Audience Award, Feature: |
Do You Wanna Dance |
| Best Actor, Feature Film: |
Noble Willingham in The Corndog Man |
| Best Supporting Actor, Feature Film: |
George Woodard in Mud Season |
| Best Supporting Actress in a Feature Film: |
Daphne Ashbrooke in Dumbarton Bridge |
| Festival Director's Maverick Film Award: |
Back By Five |
| Jury Award for Best Short Film: |
The Lonelys Director: Henry Barrial |
| Best Director, Short Film: |
J. Miller Tobin in 4 AM Open All Night |
| Audience Award, Short Film: |
Creampuff Director: Jared Seide |
| Best Actor in a Short Film: |
Matt Casada in The Lonelys |
| Best Actress in a Short Film: |
Danna Hansen in Every Night and Twice on Sundays |
| The Method Fest Lifetime Achievement Award: |
Maximillian Schell |
| The Method Fest Indie Supporter Award: |
Karen Black |
| Best Feature: |
Stanley's Gig |
| John Garfield Award for Best Actor: (tie) |
Hill Harper in The Visit |
| Geraldine Page Award for Best Actress: |
Robin Dearden in Last Chance |
| Festival Director's Breakout Filmmaking Award: |
The Young Unknowns; dir. Catherine Jelski Trash; dir. Mark Anthony Galluzzo |
| Best Director, Feature Film: |
Bryan Cranston in Last Chance |
| Best Screenplay, Feature Film: |
Post-Mortem, Screenplay by: Louis Belanger |
| Maverick Award for Quality in a Low-budget film: |
The Stonecutter, director: Stephen Ericksen |
| Audience Award, Feature Film: |
The Visit |
| Audience Award, Short Film: |
Mutual Love Life |
| Best Supporting Actor, Feature Film: |
Brent Glenen, Rollercoaster |
| Best Supporting Actress, Feature Film: |
Marla Gibbs, The Visit |
| Best Short Film: |
Boundaries, Director. Greg Durbin |
| Best Director, Short Film: |
J. Miller Tobin in 4 AM Open All Night |
| Best Actor in a Short Film: |
Allen Garfield, Men Named Milo Women Named Greta |
| Best Actress in a Short Film: |
Tippy Hedren, Mulligans! |
