User:Lquilter/Approaches
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Illustrate with diffs from existing pages if helpful.
Contents |
[edit] Page arrangement
[edit] Approach 1: WP:NOR with PSTS
- WP:NOR includes a section defining PSTS. The wording is as follows: (some stable version from the last year?)
- WP:RS looks like ....
- WP:FICT looks like ...
[edit] Approach 2: WP:RS with PSTS
- WP:NOR has PSTS section removed
- WP:RS has the PSTS section included. The text looks like:
- WP:FICT looks like ...
[edit] Approach 3: PSTS is its own page
- WP:NOR has PSTS section removed
- WP:RS looks like ...
- WP:PSTS includes the PSTS language from WP:NOR. Its status as guideline or policy is to be determined.
- WP:FICT looks like ...
[edit] PSTS language variations
Significant confusions and disagreements exist around:
- defining secondary, primary, tertiary
- applying the definitions to particular fields of endeavor, e.g., scientific publications
- prefatory language: how strong is this guidance? what is it useful for?
[edit] PSTS language variation 1
- some stable version from the past
[edit] PSTS language variation 2
- some other version from the past that is important to people and is significantly different
[edit] PSTS language variation 3
- proposal or version that started the revert war
[edit] PSTS language variation 4
- Vasayana's proposal
[edit] PSTS language variation 5
- Changing words "primary" and "secondary" to "raw"
[edit] PSTS language variation 6: SmallJim
- 12/16 SlimJim proposed a rewrite (Wikipedia talk:No original research#Shifting the PSTS paradigm
