Talk:List of Black Sabbath band members

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The stuff below is completely unintelligible, but I can only imagine you're talking about the new Dio Years tracks. These are Sabbath songs, not "Heaven & Hell" songs, and the band members themselves have referred to them as such. To date, there are no original "Heaven & Hell" songs. As of now, the band (of the original 4 members) is technically "on hiatus" and claims to be planning to release a project within the next year, and Dio and Appice are not "in" Black Sabbath at the moment. HOWEVER, we'll have to watch what happens over the next year or so, as certain circumstances could retroactively render this period to become "Black Sabbath" (i.e. Ozzy and Bill leave the band for good and the current incarnation starts touring as Sabbath, etc.). Prezuiwf 19:55, 25 June 2007 (UTC)

I know it's a late reply to you, but here it is: I made that messy, pointless speech ranting about the new Dio Years tracks. My point at the time (though I'm sick of losing arguments about technical things so won't chase it up) was that they released music as Black Sabbath together. Dio/Butler/Iommi/Appice went into the studio to make some Black Sabbath music in 2006 and released it in 2007. So they should be listed as session musicians at that time. (The Elfoid (talk) 03:59, 29 December 2007 (UTC))

Anyone willing to make a chart? It'd be much easier to read. I would, but I don't know how. The top bars would be Vocalist, Guitarist, Bassist, Drummer. The left would be the years. -Winter123 (talk) 03:01, 18 May 2008 (UTC)