User:KimvdLinde/SV-RfAR/GaryWeiss

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

In August 2006, SlimVirgin deleted a version of the article about Gary Weiss alleging that it contained personal information. However, that version does does not contain any pertinent personal information like telephone numbers, adresses or anything like that, and additions like this are normally just reverted as nonsense/vandalism/whatever. However, SlimVirgin decided to delete the version, and with that, she effectively confirms that the inserted information is actually valid. As such, I disagree with SlimVirgin that the version needed to be deleted, but agree with Dmcdevit/ArbCom that it needed to be oversighted.

[edit] Following SlimVirgin

At some point, slimVirgin accuses: Here's one example of how she's been following me around looking for the chance to cause me a problem [1]

However, User:Dmcdevit posts at the evening of Sept 3 the decision of the ArbCom to desysop EveryKing [2]., which I think was quite rightfully. I check the Admin Noticeboards so there was no following of SlimVirgin required to get to this information.

[edit] Reconstructing the diff

I admit that I was curious, and wanted to understand what was so damaging that the ArbCom found it necessary to do an emergency desysop an fellow admin. So, I checked the deleted diff, and reconstructed what was added using two documents saved in word, and doing a 'merge and compare', after which I saved the word document as I was in a hurry to get out of the door and wanted to have a look at it later (this word document is available for ArbCom members). This version got oversighted on late sept 4/early sept 5 (depending in the timezone)[3].