Talk:Kanesatake, Quebec
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
[edit] Editing tag added
There are several articles relating to Kanesatake that are drastically in need of attention due to issues of NPOV and general style problems. These include the following:
- John sha ko hen the tha Harding -
Article in need of clean-up that has NPOV problems and is about a series of incidents rather than John Harding. Text moved here. - Steven Bonspille - Stub that has POV problems (albiet abridged) similar to the above.
- James Gabriel - Well written article; not about its subject.
Discussion at Talk:John sha ko hen the tha Harding describes the problem in some detail. There is a proposal to merge that article or some of its content with Kanesatake, Quebec. I'm proposing to do that and then edit the whole mess. Sunray 01:08, 6 October 2005 (UTC)
- Most of the text from the John sha ko hen the tha Harding article has been moved to this article (Kanesatake, Quebec). It is an account by a participant and needs POV work and fact checking. References have been added under "External links." The John sha ko hen the tha Harding article needs biographical details. Sunray 17:17, 7 October 2005 (UTC)
[edit] POV-check template added
Hi, I've added the {{POV-check}} template to this article, with respect to the above-mentioned NPOV issues. Not having a great deal of accurate knowledge of the subject, I don't feel comfortable making a judgement one way or the other, but the use of such words as "obsession" and "trampling rights" seem to be definite red flags to me. Thoughts from other editors and contributors are welcomed. --dragfyre 13:43, 18 October 2006 (UTC)
