User talk:John.ohno

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Yuki Nagato

Regarding your edit to this article, one of the main underlying reasons for the revert was excessive detail. It's far too much in-universe information that was needed for the article. The details are largely unnecessary when a short summary is suitable. On the case of citing fansite/forums check WP:EL and WP:RS regarding what can and cannot be used. In the case for the Haruhi franchise check [1] for further comments on the site. It's an unofficial fansite whose accuracy and reliability is highly questionable. If you have any more questions in regards to consensus on the subject, you can direct all to the discussion page at WP:ANIME. As far as I know, linking to Baka-Tsuki is highly discouraged and if you happen to see any citations coming from that site then they should be removed. Citations should come straight from the novel itself in this case, yet should be double-checked against a more reliable account/translation for accuracy. Fox816 (talk) 05:36, 13 May 2008 (UTC)