User:Here/pov

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Contents 1 biases 2 AfDs 2.1 schools

[edit] biases

• Mergist, if anything.
• Libertarian ideally, practically 42 (number).
• Transparency is good (make watchlists public).
• The data will survive, the interface will change.

[edit] AfDs

Notability
Inclusion guidelines
Academics Books Films Music Numbers Organizations & companies People Web content
Active proposals
Aircraft Criminal acts Fiction Places and transportation Schools Serial works Streets and roads Toys and games
See also
Common deletion outcomes

See Wikipedia:AFD_100_days study for insightful look at AfD voting tendencies.

Aritles for Deletion selected interesting or close AfDs - my vote - notes and result.

• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Green Tortoise - keep - added sources, kept.
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Empornium - keep - porn site Alexa below 4k, many delete votes!? (kept)
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cdfreaks - keep - boderline WP:WEB for commercial site.
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Knight (publisher) - keep - internet publisher (no consensus)
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lintilla (chat site) - keep, merge - old talker similar to MOO/MUSH/etc. ( no concensus )
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of noteworthy raves delete, unsourced, (deleted).
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darken delete, classic web comic AfD with supporters reaching for notability. (no concensus)
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Clutchbone - delete - unverifiable (deleted)
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Spillane - delete - tv idol contestantant. (kept!)
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sai Ho - delete - theater figure (deleted)
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Windsor Hall - delete - residence hall (deleted)

see also St. Patrick’s Hall and all others in Category:University_of_Reading

• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Alexander (US Army soldier) - delete/merge - 2000th death in 2003 Iraq War. (was merged into 2003 invasion of Iraq media coverage)
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people widely considered eccentric (4th nomination) - merge - was kept.
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drunk dialing - wiktionary - no consensus
• Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gunther Eysenbach comment, self-written bio kept after acklowledgment of WP:COI.

[edit] schools

Provided verifiable; Keep; even if non-notable

• Wikipedia:Watch/schoolwatch/Votes_for_deletion_archive as precedent.
• see also Wikipedia:Schools/Arguments
• schools, feel like (to me), and by precedent are, an exception to standards of inclusion I apply to any other topic.
• Related AfDs worth considering
  • 050923 - Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Lingnan_Primary_School (See extensive valid delete arguments focused on verifiability)
  • 051019 - Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chepstow School (first contact)

I realize this is rather terse and unexplained. I've only just found the controversy and should expand upon further reflection. ∴ here…♠ 04:43, 21 October 2005 (UTC)

I also like this Wikipedia_talk:Schools#Summary, proposal suggesting keep if any of:

• 3+ sentences other than phonebook info.
• It has one or more interwiki links (e.g. another language)
• It has one or more PD/GFDL/free pictures

∴ here…♠ 19:57, 30 November 2005 (UTC)