Talk:GPapers

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Notability concerns

This is a very cool program, but I'm concerned that WP:N is not met and, given the author of the article and the app, that WP:COI may as well. Someone had nominated this for a speedy deletion, though this nomination was removed as "invalid" for some reason when wikindx (a program that has been around for longer & has better established notability through inclusion in distros, use by institutions, and by independent, non-anonymous reviews) wad speedily deleted for the same reason [1]. I PRODed this & the PROD was removed by the author without comment. I won't nominate for AfD right away because WP:ILIKEIT, but I think that is where this is headed unless notability may be established. Since gPapers is so new, I don't know if notability can be established at this time. I'd very much like for the author to prove me wrong. Otherwise, perhaps this should be deleted with no prejudice against recreation if it became notable. --Karnesky (talk) 00:19, 18 February 2008 (UTC)