User talk:Fearfior

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Gaelic Placenames

Hey Fearfior, I'm glad you got back to me! I thought the list of placenames you added was thorough and I was glad to see it, but the sheer volume of names was itself problematic. I had just submitted Canadian Gaelic for good article status, and the additions you made would surely have jeopardised the nomination. There are provisions in the rules of what constitutes a good wikipedia article against extraneous lists and enumerations, and while the informational content of your complete list was welcome, the length and the format were not appropriate for the article. Perhaps a seperate article entitled "List of Canadian Gaelic place-names" would be better served by your experience. If you see any errors that I have made, or if you feel there areone or two omissions that ought to be remedied, please feel free to do so.

So you worked for the gaelic council? A bheil Gàidhlig agaibh?—Preceding unsigned comment added by Muckapedia (talk • contribs)