User:Ed!/Reviews

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Reviews

I occasionally review GA nominees for promotion, to help clear the extensive backlog that the GA page always seems to have. This is a history of the articles I have given a GA review to, for records of anyone who wishes to look over them. I am not a picky reviewer, and I really don't mind reviewing anything, and thus do not have any partcular areas of focus when it comes to reviewing GAs. If you feel that I consistantly am judging nominees unfairly or incorrectly, please let me know. I don't pretend to be an expert on what makes an article "good".
# Article Assesment Date
1 Battle of the Little Bighorn Hold 2008-02-17
2 HMS Birkenhead (1845) Pass 2008-02-17
3 Walter Liberty Vernon Fail 2008-02-17
4 Henry Timberlake Hold 2008-02-17
5 Fernão Pires de Andrade Pass 2008-02-17
6 Linda McCartney Pass 2008-02-18
7 Irreplaceable Pass 2008-02-18
8 Boys in the Sand Hold 2008-02-18
9 Opeth Pass 2008-02-20
10 Resident Evil: Apocalypse Pass 2008-02-20
11 U.S. Route 199 Pass 2008-02-20
12 Night of the Sentinels Hold 2008-02-20
13 I Am Legend (film) Pass 2008-02-20
14 Ring the Alarm Pass 2008-02-21
15 Don Kent (wrestler) Hold 2008-02-21
16 Washington Park Race Track Hold 2008-02-21
17 Don Kent (wrestler) Pass 2008-03-08
18 Washington Park Race Track Pass 2008-03-10
19 Battle of the Little Bighorn Fail 2008-03-20
20 1926 Lithuanian coup d'état Pass 2008-03-20
21 Lachine massacre Hold 2008-03-20
22 USS Siboney (ID-2999) Hold 2008-03-20
23 USS Siboney (ID-2999) Pass 2008-03-20
24 Lachine massacre Pass 2008-03-31
25 William King (Royal Navy officer) Hold 2008-04-04
26 Wales Millennium Centre Fail 2008-04-12
27 Hulme Arch Bridge Hold 2008-04-12
28 Hulme Arch Bridge Pass 2008-04-15
29 Battle of Gettysburg, First Day Hold 2008-04-23
30 Cambodian Civil War Pass 2008-04-23
31 Byzantine-Arab Wars (780–1180) Hold 2008-04-25
32 Battle of Iwo Jima Fail 2008-04-25
33 William King (Royal Navy officer) Pass 2008-05-06
34 Byzantine-Arab Wars (780–1180) Pass 2008-05-12
35 Battle of Gettysburg, First Day Pass 2008-05-12
Totals
Pass 19
Fail 4
Hold 12
Total Reviews 35

[edit] GA Review

GA review (see here for criteria) (see here for this contributor's history of GA reviews)
  1. It is reasonably well written:
  2. It is factually accurate and verifiable:
  3. It is broad in its coverage:
  4. It follows the neutral point of view policy:
  5. It is stable:
  6. It is illustrated by images, where possible and appropriate:
  7. Overall: