Talk:Celine
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This disambiguation is insane!--Blackfield 22:14, 12 June 2006 (UTC)
- Given the fact that Celine Dion is more notoriable than Louis Ferdinand, this disambig should be a redirect to Celine Dion article, nonetheless I will make this compromise. Google yields results for Dion over Ferdinand, and Ferdinand already has the redirect from "Céline" (with the e accented). — CRAZY`(IN)`SANE 22:43, 12 June 2006 (UTC)
- Weather or not Google yields more results for Dion than Céline is not relevant. The thing is that Céline is Céline Dions first name. I bet you that virtualy nobody refers to Céline Dion as just Céline in a conversation, unless he or she knows her personally (which they most likely don’t). I propose adding something like
Céline redirects here. Céline Dion also existsto the top of the Louis-Ferdinand Céline page.
- And regarding Dion being "more notoriable": When she dies she will most likely be forgotten by the time her corpse done rotting, while Céline probably won't be forgotten in a long time considering the tremendous impact he has had on literature world wide, French literature in particular. Besides, basing who or what is more "notoriable" on the results that Google yields doesn't work. It simply doesn't work that way.
- Weather or not Google yields more results for Dion than Céline is not relevant. The thing is that Céline is Céline Dions first name. I bet you that virtualy nobody refers to Céline Dion as just Céline in a conversation, unless he or she knows her personally (which they most likely don’t). I propose adding something like
-
- Ps.
- "Notoriable" is not a word. If you don't believe me check what Google yields.--Blackfield 12:07, 13 June 2006 (UTC)
- Many people refer to Celine Dion by her first name, in the Western world. I see you are from Sweden, not from around here. If someome mentioned the name Celine in this area, they would only recognize Celine Dion. Also, as for your "proposal"..."Céline" already redirects to Louis Ferdinand-whatever, its "Celine" that has this disambiguation page. Regardless of what your opinions are, the fact is that most people in the West think of Dion when the first name Celine is mentioned, not the other person. — CRAZY`(IN)`SANE 15:51, 13 June 2006 (UTC)
Fine, if it makes you happy to have this disambiguation then let's keep it, as a monument of ignorance and bad taste.--Blackfield 07:24, 16 June 2006 (UTC)
This is probably the worst disambiguation ever.--Blackfield 14:48, 3 April 2007 (UTC)
jävla bajsaker dåliga saker —Preceding unsigned comment added by 89.253.76.224 (talk) 00:18, 2 March 2008 (UTC)
