User talk:Carolmooredc/draft chart

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Draft of proposed Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/ChartPastDiscussions

THIS IS A DRAFT OF A DRAFT, for anyone who wanders by while the draft is under construction.

This is a draft of two lists for a Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/ page also linked from Wikipedia:Reliable sources. It's goal is to list specific sources and general issues that have been or are likely to be asked about more than once so they do not have to ask about them yet again, or go searching around the archives, or require someone else to do so to answer their questions. If done in a very neutral way it's an excellent resource. (It might be good to have two lists, one for discussions that are more general even if mention one or more specific sources; another than mentions specific sources; a few sources might end up on both.)

ALPHABETICAL LIST OF PREVIOUSLY DISCUSSED SOURCES AND ISSUES

(Instructions: Once discussions have been archived, add new source and status to the table in the same format, in alphabetical order.)

SPECIFIC SOURCES and LINK(S) TO DISCUSSIONS

  • Al-Jazeera Video: #1
  • FAIRLDS.org: #1
  • Mikhail Meltyukhov: #1
  • Salon as source controversial BLP: #1
  • Tommy2.net: #1
  • University Teachers for Human Rights: #1

GENERAL ISSUES and LINK(S) TO DISCUSSIONS

  • Academic works untranslated to English: #1
  • Forums and other user-edited sources: #1
  • Mirrors of Reliable Sources: #1
  • Heavy reliance on web sources: #1
  • Published appellate court opinion in articles not about that legal case: #1
  • Published conference proceedings: #1
  • Reliable sources reproduced on personal blogs: #1


Carol Moore 17:18, 13 April 2008 (UTC)Carolmooredc {talk}