Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Magnesium Phosphoricum

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Contents

[edit] Closing administrator's remarks

If you choose to add comments to this page, please do so in a separate section below. Do not break-up my comments here.

[edit] Raw count analysis

    1. Tevildo
    2. Uncle G
    3. Nick
    4. Tim Ross
    5. Peterkingiron (3 edits)
    1. Mithent
    2. TimVickers
    • Unspecified target
  1. Bearian
  2. 88.172.132.94 (2 edits) (!voted twice, both with bolded "delete", but made a merge argument)
  3. RDOlivaw (2 edits) (!voted delete with discounted argument, and also made merge argument)
  4. SeanMD80 (!voted delete per RDOlivaw) and made a discounted argument.
  • Ignored for purposes of determining rough consensus
  1. Nick (made suggestion not directly related to the dispositioning of this article/ AFD)
  2. Adam Cuerden (2 edits) <nominator> (all delete arguments discounted)
  3. Mh29255 (discounted keep argument)

[edit] Rough consensus rationale

[edit] Discounted delete arguments

  • free of context
    • WP:STUB A stub is an article containing only a few sentences of text which is too short to provide encyclopedic coverage of a subject, but not so short as to provide no useful information.
  • Very, very short article does not even say what the substance is
  • it's questionable whether every homeopathic medicine (of which there are hundreds, if not thousands or millions) even should have its own article.
  • Also, it's been in existence a year, but noone has expanded it beyond the sentence.
  • contains no useful information, and can not be expanded much
  • "Alternative" medicine that very poorly refernced throughout the net. (SIC)

[edit] Discounted keep arguments

  • ample Internet hits for it implying notability

The overwhelming consensus was to merge/redirect. There was no clear consensus as to what target the action should be taken, I have therefore accordingly closed this as "Merge/Redirect Interested editors should discuss elsewhere and perform the required action." JERRY talk contribs 05:37, 29 January 2008 (UTC)