Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Infidel

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] What I was about to add to Infidel AFD before your premature closure...

Moved from my talk page. El_C 18:50, 30 July 2007 (UTC)

Delete - Violates WP:OR by creating a "novel narrative" about what ought to be a simple Wiktionary entry. Instead, Wikipedians are defining it as a "topic" by taking mentions from here or there about "infidel" in addition to forking content that they believe to be similar enough to warrant inclusion (i.e. kafir, dasa). Without some good sources narrating this as a topic rather than as a dictionary definition, we have nothing appropriate to base our narrative upon that provides proper scope for the article. Unless this OR issue is adequately addressed, the article should be deleted. The Behnam 18:45, 30 July 2007 (UTC)