Talk:André Raison/Comments

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I recommend a critical review of the score sample from "Trio en chaconne". If you compare it with the edition in WIMA you'll notice the initial motive in WIMA's edition has the notes

4g | 2d+ 8a 16g 16a | 2b

in the right hand upper part while the sample in the Wikipedia article has

4g | 2c+ 8a 16g 16a | 2b

Unfortunately I've not access to the original printing of "Livre d'Orgue". But from a music analysis point of view it seems obvious that the leading motive spans the chord on the first degree of the key in use (in practice g-minor). The 2c+ found in the Wikipedia sample seems most unlikely to me. Reccmo (talk) 11:02, 11 June 2008 (UTC)