User talk:Alex Nought

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Gargoyles

I'm not sure I follow, spam-ads? I could understand it they were links to fan forums that were of little true rellevance, or fanfic sites... but I feel it's different when it's the creator's blog, and the main Gargoyles convention. Surely those are the things permissible under the Wiki guidelines? -Kingpin1055 16:36, 29 April 2007 (UTC)

Not entirely. The Gargoyles Convention's link does not add any more detail than that already on the article's section. The site is not very informative, as it is mainly directed to publicize and attract people to the event, and therefore it's usage, here on Wikipedia, borderlines spam-ads. As for as Ask Greg site, which it's not entirely a creator's blog (it's a site moderated by fans, where the creator answers screened questions), there are already links on the references sections, so there's no need to have it on the external links section, per WP:EL. --Alex Nought 13:33, 5 May 2007 (UTC)