User talk:68.193.62.120

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Hey, welcome, thanks for improving that article! Sorry for the momentary revert, it looked like you were vandalizing because you removed a large amount of text. You might want to leave a note on the article's talk page about why you're removing all that so folks don't make my mistake again. Leave me a message on my talk page if you have any questions or want to discuss anything. Peace, delldot talk 17:21, 12 December 2007 (UTC)


Hi! Thanks for getting back to me. I'm really glad you're working on improving the neutrality of the article, it's one of the most important things you can do around here!
I had a look at it, and I thought the biggest problem with it was not the neutrality, but the notability; the article doesn't really explain what makes this site different from other online magazines. That is, it doesn't really justify why there should be an article about the magazine in Wikipedia (see WP:WEB for the guideline on notability for websites). Therefore I'm concerned that the article might not survive if someone nominates it for deletion. The most important thing you can do to fix this is to include citations from outside sources (i.e. independent of the magazine itself) that discuss it. If the magazine has been discussed and written about in sources like the news, that will show that the subject is notable and the article should stay. If it hasn't, the article will likely be deleted. Other than that, you can check WP:WEB, and if the site meets any of the criteria there, you should explain how it does in the article.
My last suggestion would be to create an account. It's free and easy, and it has several perks. For example, I'll know who you are if you leave a note on my page, whereas I'm probably not going to remember your IP address. Plus you get a watchlist so you can monitor changes to articles you're watching, and there's other benefits. Just a thought.
Thanks again for working to improve the 'pedia! Definitely let me know if I can be of any help with all this. Delldot on a public computer (talk) 04:24, 21 December 2007 (UTC)