User talk:152.78.98.1

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Salsa music

I tried very hard to incorporate your edits into the article on salsa music. However, we need more context to your claims. The bit about Peter Manuel's Journal of Ethnomusicology essay, for example, cites a source but does not give adequate support for its claims. It starts off by saying Manuel claims salsa is not a "music genre", but then the only evidence presented is that plena and bomba are not played in New York clubs. Note that two books by Manuel are already cited, and that several paragraphs of the article are already devoted to describing the word salsa -- your additions should go in that area. It might be best to talk about it on the talk page first, so we can work out a way to incorporate all the points-of-view (see WP:NPOV) in an unbiased fashion. Thanks. Tuf-Kat 23:54, 13 May 2006 (UTC)